The debate over Ireland’s Gambling Regulation Bill 2022 is intensifying, with Senators Lynn Ruane and Alice Mary Higgins advocating for a total ban on gambling bonuses as the bill nears final approval. The original version of the bill had included a blanket prohibition on such bonuses, but recent amendments have altered this, allowing operators to offer free bets.
The bill, which has now entered the final stages of review in the Senate (Seanad Éireann), will soon advance to the report stage, after which it is expected to become law. During this process, multiple amendments have been introduced and debated. One notable change, made in May during discussions in the lower house (Dáil Éireann), adjusted the ban to permit free bets, albeit without targeted marketing.
Ruane Pushes for Stronger Restrictions
Senator Ruane, during the Senate debate on October 2, pushed to restore the bill’s original language, seeking to prohibit all forms of bonuses and inducements. She argued that such offers, including free bets, can be harmful to younger and more vulnerable individuals. Ruane emphasized that these inducements act as a gateway into gambling, particularly for youth, and noted examples from other sectors where similar incentives have been banned.
“These types of inducements are an entry point into gambling for young people. There are clear examples of inducements being banned in different contexts,” Ruane stated, pointing to restrictions in Ireland’s national lottery, alcohol sales, and tobacco products as comparable regulatory actions. According to her, the current version of the bill remains “unbalanced” and fails to sufficiently protect players, especially younger ones, placing the burden of responsibility on operators rather than individuals.
Supporting this stance, Senator Mark Wall expressed concern over how these regulations, especially in relation to free bets, would be enforced. He questioned the ability of regulators to closely monitor compliance. “For the life of me I cannot see why [the minister]
has to introduce free bets and inducements. We want to protect the most vulnerable. We have to do so,” Wall argued, advocating for a complete prohibition as the only way to truly protect those at risk.
Concerns Over the Impact on Legal Operators
However, not all senators are in agreement. Senator John McGahon raised concerns that a blanket ban could drive gamblers to unregulated, black-market operators, where they could be exposed to even riskier practices. He argued that restricting bonuses and free bets among licensed operators may backfire, leading consumers to seek these offers elsewhere.
McGahon also highlighted the competitive challenges that legal operators would face if such restrictions were implemented. “Without the ability to communicate directly with potential customers, gambling companies are left at a significant competitive disadvantage,” he explained, noting that other industries, such as entertainment and digital services, engage in aggressive marketing to similar audiences. The senator underscored that maintaining some level of engagement between gambling companies and players is vital for keeping the market balanced and preventing an exodus to illegal platforms.
Minister James Browne Faces Pressure from Both Sides
Deputy James Browne, who has been overseeing the bill’s development, finds himself at the center of this heated debate. Browne, who does not support a complete ban on gambling bonuses, reiterated that while restrictions are necessary, completely outlawing promotions would be unrealistic. He acknowledged the difficulties in managing both sides of the argument but remained firm in his decision to allow free bets under the bill’s current framework. “I do not support the complete ban of all promotions in the gambling industry,” Browne stated, rejecting Ruane’s proposed amendment.
Despite ongoing criticisms, Browne has defended the revised approach as a balanced solution, allowing for free bets while avoiding targeted inducements that could exploit vulnerable players. The final wording of the bill will soon be finalized as the legislative process draws to a close.
As Ireland moves closer to passing this significant piece of gambling legislation, the debate highlights the ongoing struggle between player protection and industry competitiveness. Whether the proposed amendments will further shape the bill remains to be seen, but the future of gambling regulation in Ireland hangs in the balance.
Source:
Irish senators push to reintroduce full ban on bonuses, igamingbusiness.com, October 7, 2024.